Compare HP 17 and Lenovo Legion Pro 5i side by side with the specs buyers actually care about, a cleaner breakdown of strengths and tradeoffs, and a clearer verdict on which model fits different priorities.
$499.00
For buyers comparing shortlist options, this product stands out because Amazon shoppers currently rate it 4.3/5, the current listed price is $549.00, the standout feature is [powerful 8-core processor] intel core i3-n305...
$1,199.99
The Lenovo Legion Pro 5i Gen 8 is a compelling choice in the Laptops market. With 4,321 Amazon ratings averaging 4.7/5 stars, it has proven itself with real buyers. Intel Core i7-13700HX (16-core).
The table below puts the core differences in one place so buyers can quickly compare the display, performance, battery, connectivity, and value details that matter most. Highlighted cells mark the stronger value-oriented spec on each row.
| Spec | HP 17 | Lenovo Legion Pro 5i |
|---|---|---|
| CPU | intel core i3-n305 | Intel Core i7-13700HX |
| GPU | — | WinnerGeForce RTX 4060 |
| RAM | Winner64GB | 16GB |
| Storage | Winner2TB | 512GB SSD |
| Display | — | Winner16" WQXGA 240Hz IPS (2560x1600) |
| Resolution | — | WinnerWQXGA |
| Refresh Rate | — | Winner240Hz |
| Battery | — | WinnerUp to 6 hours |
| Connectivity | WinnerWi-Fi 6 | — |
| Operating System | WinnerWindows 11 | — |
| Weight | — | Winner5.4 lbs |
| User Rating | 4.3/5 | 4.7/5 |
| Current Price | Winner$499.00 | $1,199.99 |
| Model | Core i3 Family | Legion Pro 5i Gen 8 |
| Perating Ystem | WinnerWindows 11 | — |
| Olor | WinnerSilver | — |
| Pecial Eature | WinnerNumeric Keypad | — |
| Odel Ame | WinnerTPN-I139 | — |
| Ard Isk Ize | Winner128 GB | — |
| Screen Size | Winner17.3 Inches | — |
| Am Emory Nstalled Ize | Winner8 GB | — |
| Brand | WinnerHP | — |
| Raphics Ard Escription | WinnerIntegrated | — |
This matchup matters most for buyers balancing performance, display quality, battery life, and portability.
Developers and creators usually care about thermals, keyboard feel, ports, external-display support, and platform fit over benchmark numbers alone.
OS preference and ecosystem lock-in can be decisive when the hardware is already in the premium tier.
Winner: HP 17
HP 17 is the better bang-for-your-buck winner on this page because it comes out ahead on more of the specs and value signals that matter most for buyers shopping this category. It wins here because it comes out ahead on ram, gives you the stronger storage setup, comes out ahead on connectivity.
Pick the laptop that fits your workflow first: platform preference, thermals, battery life, display quality, and port flexibility usually matter more than isolated benchmark wins. Premium laptop buyers should optimize for the machine they will actually enjoy using every day.
Use the side-by-side table first, then open the deeper review pages if you want more context on setup, long-term ownership, and which model is the smarter buy for your exact priorities.